ID EN

After the 1-1 Draw Against Bali United, What Exactly Is John Herdman Looking For From the Indonesia National Team?

Thursday, 19 November 2026 | 20:06

Author: Rojes Saragih

The Indonesia National Team training camp held in Bali on 9–17 November 2026 is not merely an agenda to maintain player fitness. Under head coach John Herdman, this training camp (TC) serves as an opportunity to test squad depth, evaluate individual capabilities, and identify alternative players who fit the Garuda game system.

Hosted at the Bali United Training Center in Gianyar, this programme was attended by 22 players. The training camp schedule was also complemented by a friendly fixture against Bali United which ended in a 1-1 draw.

This result may seem unremarkable if only judged by the final scoreboard. However, there was a far greater mission behind this match. Herdman wanted to observe first-hand how players translated tactical instructions into live match situations.

Insightful perspectives on this Indonesia National Team Bali camp were discussed on the ITSMe Podcast alongside two football analysts: Sapto Haryo Rajasa and Ronny Pangemanan (better known as Bung Ropan). Moderated by Raisha and Gilang Respaty from Sentul Studio, Bogor, the discussion broke down Herdman's coaching approach and the prospects of various players securing a place in the Garuda Squad.

According to Sapto Haryo Rajasa, the match against Bali United must be analysed within the context of the training camp's core objectives. Herdman required this fixture to test players with limited senior national team experience, particularly those still in contention to fill open positions in the squad.

Players cannot rely solely on strong club form. They must also demonstrate ability to adapt to the national team system, understand teammate movement patterns, and execute coaching instructions when placed in real match scenarios.

On this front, Sapto noted Herdman's approach is highly structured. Instructions covering transition play, positional shifts, defensive organisation, and attacking build-up movement were all introduced during training, then put into practice against Bali United.

One of the main highlights was the performance of Arlyansyah Abdulmanan and Zanadin Fariz. Both young players displayed promising tactical understanding, with their on-pitch collaboration even producing the Indonesia National Team's goal during the fixture.

For Bung Ropan, opportunities like this are critical to expand Herdman's available player pool. Arlyansyah showed sufficient potential to earn future call-ups, while Zanadin also demonstrated quality that warrants serious consideration.

Even so, breaking into the main squad will not be easy. Established regulars of the Indonesia National Team retain strong positions in the pecking order. Consistent club performances and ability to meet the coach's tactical requirements will be the deciding factors.

Alongside Arlyansyah and Zanadin Fariz, other players including Noah Adnan, Adrian Wibowo, Rafael Struick, Mees Hilgers, and Alfharezzi Buffon were also under evaluation by John Herdman throughout the Bali training camp.

Adrian, for example, is assessed to still need improvements to match fitness after an extended period without competitive playing minutes. Meanwhile Rafael performed well in his defensive support role, though contributing goals remains an area for him to develop.

For Herdman, this evaluation process provides a far more complete picture of each player's character and capabilities. He is not only searching for technically gifted individuals, but also players who can operate within a structured system and understand collective team responsibilities.

As such, the 1-1 draw against Bali United is not the only conclusion from this Bali training camp. Far more valuable outcomes were the chance to test players, build squad depth, and trial new on-field combinations.

The question now stands: who will maintain this momentum and break through the competition for the next Garuda squad? Arlyansyah and Zanadin Fariz have already sent positive signals. However, true confirmation will require consistent performances at club level, plus capitalising on any future opportunities with the Indonesia National Team.